Ordinary Chinese Angry at North Korea

by Richardson ~ October 16th, 2006. Filed under: China-Korea Relations.

Average Chinese citizens are angry with North Korea for testing a nuclear weapon, but also harbor anti-American attitudes. Surprisingly, according to the article, a majority of Chinese believe China should “abandon” North Korea, although they aren’t likely to have much influence with policy makers. From USA Today:

By claiming to test a nuclear device, North Korea has set off a wave of anger among ordinary Chinese, who appear split about whether blame lies with North Korea or the United States.

[…]

Many said a nuclear-armed North Korea meant less security for China and East Asia. They called into question China’s historic role as North Korea’s ally and patron. Others suggested North Korea is right to arm itself in response to U.S. and Japanese threats against it.

Pyongyang’s nuclear bombshell left Zhai Huixia, 24, “shocked and furious.” The Beijing graduate school student said North Korea’s move “seems very selfish, intruding on Chinese interests, and aggravating turbulence in the region.”

For Korean War veteran Zhang Zeshi, North Korea’s claim was a bitter betrayal by an “evil” regime. “We have given them so much food, fuel and support, but they don’t listen to us,” he said.

Zhang, 77, was among more than a million Chinese soldiers sent by Mao Zedong to fight with North Korea in the 1950-53 Korean War. He spent two years in a South Korean POW camp. He was imprisoned again when he returned home, disgraced along with other former POWs for failing to die in battle against American “aggressors.”

“We spilled our blood in vain,” Zhang said. “It kept alive (North Korea’s) feudal dictatorship.”

Other Chinese saw North Korea’s decision to go nuclear as a response to pressure by the United States, which has tried to isolate the regime headed by Kim Jong Il.

“Maybe the North Korean government would already have collapsed if the U.S. adopted an enlightened policy towards it,” said Wang Miao, 25, an electrical engineer in the eastern city of Nanjing. He blamed America’s “high-pressure … Cold War strategy” for forcing Pyongyang’s hand.

[…]

In China’s swelling cyberspace, North Korea has provoked debate. On the forum at beelinkclub.com, based in eastern Shandong province, moderator Xiaocao Qiqiang called the United States and Japan warmongers. He argued that a nuclear North Korea would guarantee peace by forcing the United States and Japan to ease up.

[…]

Liu said much of the debate is colored by a “strong anti-American sentiment among many of the most informed Chinese citizens.” Liu said many of those commenting “are sympathetic to North Koreans and see a vast U.S. conspiracy to undermine China.”

[…]

The outpouring of anger — against both North Korea and the United States — is no accident, said Shen Dingli, a foreign policy specialist at Shanghai’s Fudan University. The Chinese government “has the ability to censor opinion, but it has intentionally allowed public debate to let the both the U.S. and North Korea know we are unhappy,” Shen said. “When the criticism is against Chinese foreign policy, the freedom will be less.”

A majority of Chinese believe “we should abandon” North Korea, though their view is unlikely to sway decision-makers in Beijing, Shen said. North Korea “may no longer be our friend,” he said. But its strategic value to China as a counterweight to U.S. and Japanese interests means “we must never build it into our enemy.”

3 Responses to Ordinary Chinese Angry at North Korea

  1. james

    The article correctly notes that the PRC has deliberately allowed the debate to focus anger on both the US and DPRK, but that’s to be expected. The main point is that the PRC has allowed unprecedented animosity to be directed, via public forums, towards the DPRK. This is not to be undervalued in terms of China’s development towards a more open society. The PRC may think allowing this debate suits it’s immediate purpose of letting the DRPK know that it’s upset, but the long term effect, perhaps unintentional, will be the continued expectation by the masses to vent thier anger towards other issues, perhaps even towards the party itself.

    China fails to realize that it cannot simply turn on and off any kind of free speech, and once it’s excercised, the people will demand more and more.

    Ironically, perhaps the standoff with the DPRK will also serve to hasten the collapse of one-party rule in China…

  2. Richardson

    Although I don’t think the public display of animosity towards North Korea is unprecedented – the Red Guards led much worse during the Sino-Korean dispute of the 1960s – I believe your assessment that China is allowing (encouraging from behind the scenes?) this sentiment towards North Korea rather than its own policies that allow the regime to survive.

    It would indeed be ironic is dealing with the DPRK loosened the CCP’s grip on the system.

  3. Champson

    James, you fail to recognize that free speech online unrelated to the one-Party rule in China is usually not restrcited by the government and the Chinese government is not “turning on and off any kind of free speech”.

    True there is Internet censur, but they are mainly connected with topics the government feel to be disruptive against the one-party rule. The Internet police wouldn’t care Chinese netizens criticize US, UK, Japan or DPRK. Please don’t assume the government can manipulate everything here.

    By the way, China does not need to let DPRK know “its immediate purpose of letting the DRPK know that it’s upset” by means of pushing netizens to vent anger online, for there is no Internet user in the DPRK .

Leave a Reply

Subscribe without commenting